I've worked them for two weeks now and they are pretty comfy after being broken in. they had a bit more arch support than i thought they would so definitely not for flat footed people. They look good and get the job done so overall i'm satisfied

Seemed very narrow for a "medium" but probably very comfortable once broken in

No Warranty

Not a very durable boot chunks falling out of the sole the first week. Threads coming unstitched I contacted Carhartt for possible warranty/replacement and basically told me I'm out of luck.

Best Work Boot

I got these boots for work and wore them for 2 years every day. Wore them outttt. Tried to hop on the trend of the "brunt" boots. Immediately sent those back and got MY Carharrt boots back. Best boots out!

Disgusting

After less than three months, the inside on the right heel ripped inside my boot. My laces ripped away before that. Very, very disappointed with the brand and the horrible quality these boots were

Outstanding.

I give these boots at 10/10. Very little break in needed, comfortable right out of the box. The leather is rugged and looks good as new with a quick wipe down or brushing. These are great in the garden, yard, or on a hike. I am very pleased. They look great with my Carhartt pants and shirts.

They are great. Still need to break fully in. Feel pretty good doing

Not Impressed

I'm sorry to say these are the most uncomfortable boots I have ever owned. The insert was removed after the first work day with these boots, my legs and lower back were on fire. The insert is just hard rubber, or so it feels. Threw in some heavy duty dr Scholls and a huge difference. Still they feel like your walking barefoot on concrete. Long break in, almost indefinitely long. Still feeling stiff and restricted, uncomfortable. Not to mention the tounge design is horrific. Extra stichting rubs your foot leaving it raw and painfull, especially on your ankles. It's always shifting side to side no matter how tight you make them, which you can't cause the shoelaces are so thin, you hurt your finger pulling fine stringlike laces. Im not a wide toe in any other boot or shoe, and yet these are stupid tight around my foot. Definitely get a wide toe if you still wanna try these boots. For me this is just not acceptable in the slightest for a huge brand like carhartt.

Stylish And Functional

Purchased these boots for casual outings. They look fantastic and have already recieved several compliments. Took a few days to break in a little and now they feel great. Overall they seem like a durable, high quality boot that will last a good while.

Great Boots 100% Tested

Worth the money, for me they lasted little over than a year but I work 12 hour shifts between 40-60 hrs a week in a recycling plant in AZ and we are exposed to kinda harsh conditions daily (dry/dusty areas and wet areas with puddles too), not too mention the +100 degree summer temps we get so they worked fine for me. I tried different good/expensive brands of work boots and most of them last me around the same time because of my work conditions and demand so I decide to get carhartt by choice I like the brand and styles.

Best Boot On The Mary

I have these boots for 2 years now best pair of boots I've ever bought! They are comfy and hold up very well in all elements of weather! Unfortunately after two years of hard wear and tear they finally broke down

Look Nice, Feel Good, Will Update.

Had to go half a size down (from a 10W to a 9.5W) but they feel good. Sole feels a little hard but am putting in PowerStep ProTech Insoles. Will update how they hold up after six months.

They ripped 2 weeks into wearing them. On top of the toe. Not very thrilled about it

Worth Every Penny

I've gone through many different kinds of steel toes, but these by far are the best. They're very comfortable and the insoles have incredible arch support. My feet didn't hurt breaking these boots in for the first few times I wore them. The outer material around the toe is very durable, it dosent just scrape off or chip every time something hits or falls on it. The waterproof feature is my favorite and it keeps your feet dry all day if you're in the rain. I would absolutely recommend these boots.

Functional, Visually Appealing, High Quality.

The Boots are of very nice quality. I haven't had any complaints with them. The waterproofing is super nice but they get very humid if worn on a warmer day.